4 min read

Float, Don't Flail

Suleika Jaouad's phrase came back to the group, and everyone recognized themselves in it. It is water safety advice at heart, and it works as a quick, honest check on where you are in any given moment, especially a hard one.

What I know, but have to keep reminding myself, is to float, not flail. Flailing is seductive. Flailing gives you something to do. It creates the sensation of agency, even when you have none. Floating requires something far more difficult from me: to breathe, to stop fighting the water, to trust that it might hold me.

Right now, I am here.

Suleika Jaouad, Float, Don’t Flail

This phrase had come up in an earlier meeting, and it came back this time because it would not let go of us. Everyone in the room recognized themselves in it.

It comes from Suleika Jaouad, the writer behind The Isolation Journals and author of Between Two Kingdoms, her memoir of living with leukemia. The passage above is from her October essay of the same name.

Where the Advice Comes From

The phrase sounds like a metaphor, but it began as real survival advice. The RNLI, the lifeboat charity in the UK and Ireland, built a whole water safety campaign around it called Float to Live.

When someone falls into cold water, the body’s first reaction is to gasp and thrash. That instinct is exactly the wrong one. Flailing makes it more likely to breathe in water, puts more strain on the heart, and pushes the air out of your clothes that was helping you stay up. The advice is to fight the instinct, lean back, and float. The worst of the shock passes in about a minute to a minute and a half. Once breathing settles, a person can look around and decide what to do next: swim, signal, or wait for help (RNLI).

Why It Fits Caregiving

Many of us know the flailing version well. The fall in the night, the new diagnosis, the call from the facility. The instinct is to do everything at once: fifteen phone calls, three browser tabs, a plan for every possibility, all before breakfast. It feels like action. A lot of the time it is thrashing.

Jaouad names exactly why it is so hard to stop: flailing is seductive. It gives us something to do. For caregivers, who so often have very little real control over what is happening, that sensation of agency can be hard to put down, even when it is wearing us out.

Floating is not giving up, and it is not the same as being calm or fine. The water is still cold. Floating is staying up long enough to breathe, to see where you actually are, and to choose the next stroke instead of every stroke at once. As she puts it, it asks something harder of us: to stop fighting the water, and to trust that it might hold us.

A Litmus Test

What the group kept coming back to is how simple the phrase is, which is what makes it useful. There is no checklist. There is one question:

Am I floating or flailing right now?

We would like to offer it to everyone as a litmus test for where you are in any given moment, and especially when you are facing something hard. You might notice flailing as short breath, saying yes to everything, starting five things and finishing none, or not being able to hear what someone just told you. Floating can look like one deep breath, one phone call, one decision, and letting the rest wait a minute.

Nobody floats all the time. Everyone in that room has flailed, some of us this week. The point is not to grade yourself. The point is to notice, because noticing is often the moment the floating starts. Jaouad’s last line is a good model for that kind of noticing, plain and without judgment: Right now, I am here.

This question turned out to matter for the rest of the hour, too. It is the honest answer hiding inside the question we talked about next: How Is the Caregiver?